Friday, September 12, 2008

Sad story from India

Via Discover, this shit depresses the hell out of me.
A teenage girl in central India killed herself on Wednesday after being traumatized by media reports that a "Big Bang" experiment in Europe could bring about the end of the world, her father said.

It would have been a funny story to laugh at the silly culture that takes unfounded doomsayers too literally, or a media outlet over selling the credibility of kooks for better ratings, except for the fact that a teenage girl is dead.

Now, the fact that she did this obviously shows she had some mental health issues to start with, so I'm not blaming others for her death. But I was particularly bothered by this quote from her father:
"We tried to divert her attention and told her she should not worry about such things, but to no avail," he said.

Divert her attention? I could maybe buy that as reasonable parenting if there were a real threat that they simply couldn't do anything about, like a tsunami or something. But in this case, we have a world of credible, demonstrable evidence available that there was absolutely nothing to worry about. All he had to do was treat his daughter like an adult, which is, unfortunately, about the last resort many parents will take.

He wasn't the only idiot around though:
But in deeply religious and superstitious India, fears about the experiment and the minor risks associated with it spread rapidly through the media.

In east India, thousands of people rushed to temples to pray and fast while others savored their favorite foods in anticipation of the world's end.


I don't know how much MSNBC is over selling this point. I'd be interested what percentage of Indian citizens really took the threat seriously.

4 comments:

mark said...

seriously, if someone had just reasoned with her she would have been fine. Because the reasonable response to the end of the world is suicide.

Philip said...

The point isn't what a reasonable response to the end of the world is, it's that a reasonable response to the Large Hadron Collider is that it's not going end the world.

mark said...

People don't make decisions through reason. Especially people who kill themselves. You don't, I don't. No one does. So providing information to a disturbed person is not going to solve the problem. People are driven by their beliefs and beliefs are changed over time as people experience things the challenge and change thier beliefs.

Philip said...

People don't make decisions through reason.

Then why do we have brains?

People are driven by their beliefs and beliefs are changed over time as people experience things the challenge and change thier beliefs.

You don't think a superstitious and paranoid culture and media foolishly reporting on the danger of the LHC destroying the world - you don't think that affected her beliefs?